doyle | (no subject)

(no subject)

http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/news/cult/news/drwho/2006/06/15/32946.shtml

So Rose is gone at the end of the season. My immediate reaction was "dammit, didn't I make a bet with nos at some point that she'd be there till about episode 3 of season 3? I hope I didn't promise pr0n."

People who really adore Rose and the ship: I'm sorry, I know you must be upset and irked at people celebrating, but I do think this'll be good for the show. I'm Rose and ship-neutral - there are episodes where I love her/the ship madly and episodes where I cringe - but I've been really looking forward to seeing Ten with a new companion. One who's all his own and didn't travel with Nine first would be good, but I'm dying to have Jack back full time too. Two of them, please, Rusty? A boy'n'girl TARDIS team? Because going on past evidence - Ian & Barbara & interchangeable girl, Ben & Polly, Jamie & Victoria, Jamie & Zoe, Harry & Sarah, Tegan & Turlough, Fitz & Anji/Compassion/Trix - I like that setup very much indeed.

Or, indeed, two girls a la Tegan and Nyssa. Then there could be femslash? *hopes*

I doubt Rose will be killed off, whatever The Sun says. It seems too brutal for the kids - and yes, they did it with Adric, but he was one of three, not the sole companion/kiddie identification figure, and when they tried it with Peri they were forced into a crappy retcon. I'm guessing some sort of fake-out where she seems to be dead. But then, I'm in the minority that wants her to go home to her mum and realise her life is what she makes it, that she doesn't need the magic timeship to do something worthwhile in the world. ~~Plus that makes the Rose/Sarah so much easier~~.

ETA: my housemate Kevin sez "if I had to guess, I would say the new companion will be played by... CHRISTOPHER ECCLESTON."

I would *never stop laughing.*

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

So Rose is gone at the end of the season. My immediate reaction was "dammit, didn't I make a bet with nos at some point that she'd be there till about episode 3 of season 3? I hope I didn't promise pr0n."

YOU OWE ME PORN

*cries* I lose at porn. I am always "erm, there are bits... and some other bits... and NOBODY WILL STOP TALKING AND GET ON WITH IT..."

That's exactly like all my action scenes!

If you let them talk while you keep nudging them to combine bits you can turn every single PWP into a real story, though. *not that she's talking from experience or anything*

You know, despite my Ten/Rose bias, I'm really looking forward to him having a new companion. You're right - it will be pretty interesting to see him have one (or two) that's all his own.

I don't really know if I can see Rose going home after what she went through in PotW, but Rose/SJ would be awesome. Not that it would happen unless RTD overdoses on something. I'm kind of clueless as to how Rose will exit, though - if I had my way, she'd end up with Jack somehow, but there's Torchwood. Grump. I just don't think she'll die.

if I had my way, she'd end up with Jack somehow

Rose/Jack = love. Flirty, snarky, definitely-not-monogamous time-travelling love.

ooh, i'm glad i clicked through! i'm pretty neutral too, so i'm excited about the possibilities with a new companion.

I wish they could have kept Mickey. I'd be so interested in seeing him decide to stay on without Rose.

ooh yeah! -that- would have been interesting. besides, i've always been much more fond of mickey than i am of rose.

Mickey's a character type I adore, self-styled losers who are more heroic than they think. I wish he could have stuck around for longer - at least got a proper adventure.

But then, I'm in the minority that wants her to go home to her mum and realise her life is what she makes it, that she doesn't need the magic timeship to do something worthwhile in the world.

No, that's what I want too - or at least for her to see that as a possibility. 'Cos it's a perfectly good ending, and I remain ticked at people who can't see that.

Especially given the "yay humans!" recurring theme, and the idea that the Doctor makes people better, even if he's not consciously trying to. I really love the idea of Rose going back to the same world, but it's made better because *she's* been changed. (And not in the 'vortex made her superhuman' sense because I can't see that as anything but a tragedy for her.)

Seconding this! The end of "The Age of Steel" makes me think that that would be the perfect Rose departure, to go and actually have that fantastic life Nine talked about. And then Mickey and Mrs. Moore can be the new companions. :-D

I want Rose to realise the magic timeship isn't needed, but she keeps thinking of the doctor and excitement and travel as being so much better than being trapped back home.

And I keep thinking Torchwood or UNIT would like someone who's worked with the Doctor. Particularly when she's protected the Prime Minister from aliens and so on.

I'm in the minority that wants her to go home to her mum and realise her life is what she makes it, that she doesn't need the magic timeship to do something worthwhile in the world.

Totally with you on that. That's what would make her arc work: POTW makes sense in its context, but does pretty much suggest that she can't have any purpose whatsoever as just some ordinary human on Earth, which is a depressing prospect for, well, all of us. Whereas Rose who has travelled and then learned stuff and then can use that to be a useful and valuable and productive individual, for herself, not just for him, and do Good Things at home? That's the ending she should have. I want her to take charge of her own destiny, too: not for it to be 'does the Doctor choose the Universe over her?' but 'what does Rose choose for herself?' Empowerment for the kidz and that.

I do wonder a bit at why they are telling us. I mean, they seem to be handling it in a slightly more thought-out PR way than the Eccles disaster, but they'd done a bang up job of just saying nothin' when the rumours bounced round over contracts and pay and then again at the start of this season. I liked that strategy.

I want Jackie to be the new companion. :P

my housemate Kevin sez "if I had to guess, I would say the new companion will be played by... CHRISTOPHER ECCLESTON."

Lol!

In my head, Rose goes home and opens up a detective agency with Sarah Jane and K9 as their back-up. And the Brig stops by occasionally. And so does Jack, when they're getting to close to something Torchwood is investigating and K9 thinks they should back off, but Jack'll let them do any kind of digging on "top secret" things, as long as they give him sex.

That's my story, and I'm sticking to it.

I would love that show so much I would have its babies.

And I am not a baby fan.

And the Brig would bring them lovely, lovely flowers. And they shall have a pet cat which adores K9, much to K9's charign.

Clearly, the BBC needs to be alerted to this, because it would be the best Doctor Who spin-off ever.

The man in front of her desk was gorgeous, Sarah Jane had to admit that. But only to Rose, not to him.

He smiled at her, and she could almost hear the birds singing. It looked like he could, too.

She would definitely not admit that to him.

He said, "So you're the 'Smith & Tyler Detective Agency'? I thought it was traditional for private eyes to use 'Smith & Wesson'?"

"We tend to use cell phones rather than guns, Mister ..."

"Jack Harkness," Rose's voice came from the open door behind him. A year ago when they'd started the agency, Rose would have thrown herself at an old friend, just for the reassurance of seeing him. Now she still beamed at him, but instead of coming in, she leaned against the doorframe. She tossed him a banana, and it seemed to mean something to him, because Jack Harkness burst out laughing.

You? Are now my hero. XD

I'm glad you like! I like your suggestion a lot.

They should have dangerous adventures with evil villians, and silly adventures with wacky aliens, and Jack and Sarah Jane should have romantic adventures together (because really, Sarah Jane *deserves* some good loving from a time traveller, and I bet that Jack would be happy to oblige). And all four of them (Rose, Sarah Jane, Jack, and K-9) should make snarky comments about sonic this and sonic that. And they miss the Doctor, but they don't *need* him. Not like they used to.

Darn. I may have to write this.

Um. The anonymous comment was me.

Yay! That was great. :D

Meeep! She oughtn't to diiieee!!! I don't mind if she leaves but she can't diiiiieeeeee!!!!

I like the Doctor+girl+boy configuration too. Can we have Jack back, kthanx?

I would like to see Rose leave The Doctor of her own accord and be empowered and stuff but I have a feeling that she is going to die saving the universe. Which would be okay just as long as it's her making a choice and sacrificing herself rather than her fate being left up to a whim of The Doctor's again.

All the reactions I've read have been split pretty evenly between 'No, she should never leave, she should stay forever and make time babies with the Doctor' and 'Yes, she should go hame and make femslash with Sarah Jane'

I'm of the latter camp. I do hope she doesn't die though, then again it was only the Sun that reported that and I do try not to believe anything I read in the sun.

Oooh, I didn't actually know about this until my curiosity overcame me and I clicked the cut XD but to be fair, I wasn't overly surprised when I did read... my mind's been working since that line about Rose dying in last week's episode and to be honest, it's been kind of... it's not that I don't like her, I do like Rose, just her character has been all over the place this season and it's like PICK A CHARACTERIZATION AND STICK WITH IT

However, it does make me kind of wonder what'll happen... not just "how will she leave the show?" but how it'll affect the audience... one of my main little worries about the whole new series is how they've managed to build up Rose's backstory and family so much that getting rid of Rose means getting rid of a huge chunk of that too, if that makes any sense... though I mean, they've already got rid of Mickey, so I don't know. I'd kind of hoped that if/when Rose left Mickey would come on board the Tardis as the new companion, but I guess that won't be happening now x_X

Maybe she'll like... end up merging into the Tardis or something. Because she's HOMGSOSPECIAL and the Doctor clearly can't live without her, so maybe something like that?

Hrm, whatever happens, it'll be interesting to see how this plays out...

And dude, Eccleston as a companion would be the best thing ever XDDDD

I'd kind of hoped that if/when Rose left Mickey would come on board the Tardis as the new companion, but I guess that won't be happening now x_X

Me too. But at least he's off fighting Cybermen with his nice boyfriend.

I'm in the minority that wants her to go home to her mum and realise her life is what she makes it, that she doesn't need the magic timeship to do something worthwhile in the world.

I would like that too - and maybe the Sarah Jane ep was foreshadowing for that? (Though there's certainly been plenty of "Rose dies" foreshadowing too.)

I completely agree with you -- Rose needs to see that she can make something of her life on her own, without the Doctor as introducer of new worlds, without Mickey as reliable fallback boyfriend. I want her to go back to school and get a real career and have Sarah Jane as her mentor.

And there could be femslash if there wanted to be. . . .

It messes up my fic idea where Rose leaves the Doctor for Sarah Jane when she's much older (he leaves her somewhere for five minutes and comes back five to ten years later), but I can always go AU at a to-be-decided point in this series.

But I'd still like to see her go home in canon too.

It's been coming since School Reunion, and they've been building on it with GitF, the Cybermen arc, and this last arc as well. I heard Billie had signed on for Season 3 somewhere, but meh. It's over.

I think they're going to introduce a boatload of little companion candidates over the next few episodes. It'd be a cute little promo: "Who does the Doctor pick? Find out on Tardis Control!" (Parental control on MTV where the parents say that the bf/gf is an asshat and give them new people to pick from). Oh, if Lynda with a Y had lived.

He could pick all of them! And then keep them on a rota!

I'm in the minority that wants her to go home to her mum and realise her life is what she makes it, that she doesn't need the magic timeship to do something worthwhile in the world.

Count me there, because it's the most fitting end for her.

My main reaction to the news is relief -- now, thank God, I know they're going to follow through on the hints which have been dropped rather than having to back-pedal wildly at the season's end. As others have noted, Rose's characterisation has been all over the shop this season, and what precious little consistency there has been has related to the foreshadowing of her future. At this point in the season, I feel like Rose's character can only make sense if she's leaving.

I don't think they'll *KILL* kill her -- not on BBC1 at 7 o'clock on a Saturday. If the show aired at 9pm on BBC3, then maybe, but I don't believe they'll go that dark. My current guess is that Rose may *technically* die, just for long enough to fulfill Faux!Satan's prophecy.

Yay to the idea of a girl/boy companion team: that would be a lot of fun, and a completely fresh dynamic for the new DW.

I'm in the minority that wants her to go home to her mum and realise her life is what she makes it, that she doesn't need the magic timeship to do something worthwhile in the world.

Hear, hear.

Yeah, I'm right there with you on the "Yes!" Not because I don't like Rose, but because with this news suddenly I can see the sense in all her OOC behavior this season. She's become so much stronger without him than when he's around, as Satan Pit showed so clearly. I think she feels somehow that being proactive and independent is what killed him in the first place, and she doesn't want to be responsible for that happening again, so she's become completely passive. Now she'll realize that and that she needs to move on, for both their sakes. It will all be good.

And there's always Jack...

But then, I'm in the minority that wants her to go home to her mum and realise her life is what she makes it, that she doesn't need the magic timeship to do something worthwhile in the world.

Oh, I want this to happen the most.

Although I just realized with Rose leaving, there may not be any more Jackie and I am very surprised by how sad that makes me. Dammit, I got really attached to Jackie.

And there will never be canon Tenth Doctor/Rose/Jack. Only in my dreams. Heh.

I do hope Jack does show up in Series Three and I am very curious about the next companion/companions.

Though I'll miss Rose, I hope her story ends in a way that feels earned. I think killing her off though, that would suck and my sister the Cuppy (aged 11) will kill me for getting her hooked into a show where her beloved Ninth Doctor and Rose died.

I'm really sad at Rose not getting to see Jack again, but there's always fic.

I'm surprised how attached I got to Jackie, too. Not as much as to Mickey, but then Mickey somehow became my second-favourite after the Doctor, which I could never have predicted back in the first episode.

Oh, Mickey. He did get an excellent send off at the very least.

But I'm still amazed by how much I will miss Jackie. When I found out she was in many eps of S1, after seeing Rose, I was not teribly happy, and then, I just loved her to bits.

I'd just like to counteract all the "not because I don't like Rose, because I do like Rose" and say: this makes me blissfully happy because I hated Rose in S1 and have zero desire to watch S2 as a consequence and it gives me hope for being able to watch S3.

But then, I'm in the minority that wants her to go home to her mum and realise her life is what she makes it, that she doesn't need the magic timeship to do something worthwhile in the world.

I really hate 'you must abandon the exciting adventures and go home and get a job/get married/whatever because that's what growing up means' ends to kids stories, so I don't want this. Especially because Rose, and I do love her, basically has zero concrete skills. And she's never shown any sort of interest in academics so the 'I'm going off to college and getting a real job/going to work for the peace corps' is just not very believable.

The goes-to-work-for-Torchwood ending would be acceptable, though.

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

(no subject)

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

Oh thank you!

Re: Oh thank you!

Re: Oh thank you!

Re: Oh thank you!

Re: Oh thank you!

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject